K-Palette 1 Day Tattoo Real Lasting Eyeliner 24h WP(Micro) vs. Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliner

Top hats

K-Palette, why do you have to be so freaking verbose? You have such a tiny little brush, but such a fat name.

Ok, so these are two liquid drugstore eyeliners that both retail for 1260 Yen (around £10 or $15). The K-Palette 1 Day Tattoo line is made up of products for brows and eye-lining, and Dolly Wink is well-known for its eyeliner and false eyelashes.

Peas and Carrots

Let’s get down to business.

Overview

Japanese liquid eyeliners in general are said to be better than their Western counterparts. Now, I’m sure there are exceptions to this rule (as always with sweeping generalisations) but both these eyeliners come out top over any I’ve tried before (though my experience with liquid liner isn’t huge).

Both eyeliners are very good: they’re both long-lasting and they both have those lovely brush-type applicators that allow for loads of control but have enough flex to give a natural flick.

Applicators

Looking Fine

As you can see the K-Palette tip is super fine (it is the ‘micro’ version after all – they also have a regular version available) and makes the Dolly Wink look unfairly big in comparison, but the Dolly Wink is also pretty fine in the grand scheme of liquid eyeliners.

The K-Palette brush is also a little shorter. With any fine-tipped eyeliner brush, there’s a danger of floppiness if the brush is too long. The K-Palette’s shorter tip means the brush is stiffer and, therefore, easier to control.

K Palette on the Left Dolly Wink on the Right

As someone who’s a bit challenged when it comes to eyeliner flicks, wings and other general embellishments, I prefer the K-Palette’s tiny applicator. I can start off with a fine line and build up to the thickness I want, and mistakes are hardly noticeable because they’re so small.

If you’re looking for precision, K-Palette Micro is the way to go.

In Action

I need to work on my handwriting

Ok so here are a bunch of examples of both eyeliners.

From the top:

  • How the eyeliner builds on itself
  • General liney stuff (excuse my atrocious ‘P’ of ‘Palette’)
  • More lines, this time the same image so you can compare the two fairly
  • The lightest possible line I can draw with each pen – I had to do the K-Palette twice
  • A thick line, pushing down on the brush to make it bend

Things to note:

  • Both build up well with no pilling, the Dolly Wink is a little bit blacker.
  • The Dolly Wink’s line can be quite thick, but also (look at the ‘n’ of ‘wink’) can be narrowed down. The K-Palette is a little less wet than the Dolly Wink (I’ve had the K-Palette for one month longer than the Dolly Wink, so it may be down to that) and so its line in the writing is not as smooth.
  • Same as above.
  • The Dolly Wink can actually draw a very thin line, but I find it quite difficult to get a line this consistently thin when applying it on my eye.
  • The thickest lines are actually very similar, both eyeliners are very versatile.

My New Tattoo

Here you can see the two in action on skin.

  • The Dolly Wink is a whole lot blacker, however (though this isn’t evident in the picture) the K-Palette’s blackness can be built up.
  • Again, the K-Palette is crazy fine – look at the bottom flick of the ‘K’.

Lasting Power

I find that these two are neck and neck when it comes to lasting power.

According to the K-Palette website, the 1 Day Tattoo WP eyeliner is a tubing eyeliner, meaning that while it will come off with warm water and pressure, it won’t budge when faced with oil, sweat, or cold water. The Dolly Wink website doesn’t say explicitly whether their liner is tubing or not, but they do say that ‘although it’s resistant to sweat and water, you can take it off easily when you cleanse’.

When testing them myself I found that:

  • Both looked freshly applied at the end of a day of ordinary wear.
  • Both withstood cold water completely.
  • Both withstood cleansing oil very well, but when pressure was added they eventually gave in.
  • Both withstood lots of pressure and rubbing when they were on my hand, but only medium pressure when actually applied on eyes.

The last point is important. In general, with ordinary wear, these eyeliners will last all day – they wear like iron. However, if you rub your eyes often, you can get into some trouble. The eyeliners don’t smudge per se, they actually kind of…ball up. That is to say that the ink comes off and moves as little flecks, without leaving any smudgy residue behind. This balling is more likely to happen when the eyeliner has been layered more. So for example, one swipe of liner will withstand quite a bit of pressure, so you don’t have to run to a mirror every time you’ve inadvertently rubbed your eyes. However, if you’ve gone over the line a couple of times, just one rub can cause some flecks to come off.

Because of this, Dolly Wink is actually a little ahead of the K-Palette. Why? Because to get the level of blackness (and thickness) you get from one swipe of the Dolly Wink, you have to layer a few swipes of the K-Palette, which means it’s more susceptible to this pilling.

The Bottom Line

Both eyeliners are really excellent, and there’s not a lot between them. If you’re not so great at eye lining, you may prefer the K-Palette Micro because of its precision. If you’re after an eyeliner of regular thickness, you’ll be impressed by the Dolly Wink’s control, lasting power, and inky blackness.

Kate Lasting Gel Eyeliners in BK-2 and BU-1

Kate is a reasonably priced, widely-available Japanese drugstore brand.
These eyeliners retail for 1155 yen (£9.32/$14.98).

Kate Lasting Gel Eyeliners are a solid favourite among beauty enthusiasts, outperforming most high-end liners in terms of lasting power, manageability, and pigmentation.

Lasting Power

I graduated to these liners after using MAC fluidlines for a couple of years. I would say the biggest difference between the two is lasting power. After a wipe test MAC dipdown was reduced to a questionable stain on my arm while the Kate was hardly affected. In the shower, the rest of the MAC came off with a bit of water and pressure. The Kate withstood water and shower gel, and only started to fade with make-up remover and painful rubbing. I eventually gave up trying to remove all of it: my arm was sore and the hot water was running out, so I left the remainder of the Kate (by now a stain) on my wrist for the next couple of days.

Kate gel eyeliners are without a doubt the most long-lasting eyeliners I have ever tried.

Ease of Use

Now this is where my opinion seems to deviate from the general consensus.

I find that I have to expend a little more effort on applying Kate gel eyeliner than I do on, say, Bobbi Brown’s gel eyeliner.  Not a lot more, mind you.

I think that the unparalleled lasting power of Kate eyeliners results in some ‘slip’ being lost. I find that the liners don’t glide very smoothly along my eyelid. However, this problem is very minor, it results in maybe one minute of extra attention being spent on eyeliner than usual, and this is a small price to pay for such a long-lasting line. Of course if you don’t need extra staying power for your eyeliner, then this disadvantage may have more weight in your buying decision.

Colour

The Lasting Gel Eyeliners come in a variety of natural shades. Even the blue, which looks very vibrant when built up in the swatch below, can easily pass as a natural liner shade when applied properly. I appreciate that Kate offers different nuances of shades instead of confining its consumers to one catch-all black or brown.

Pigmentation

It seems Kate Lasting Gel Eyeliners are not all created equal. I love the pigmentation of BK-2: it applies opaquely on to the eyelid in one stroke. BU-1, however, is a different story. I find myself having to smother my brush in the liner until a visible chunk of the product is stuck to my brush in order to get an opaque line. Just dipping the brush in and applying gives me a sheer and uneven line. Of course this line can be built up to desired opacity. I still like BU-1, but it’s a shame that it doesn’t live up to the well-earned reputation of its siblings. (Having swatched it with my finger though, it looks like it would make a fantastic eyeshadow base).

The Bottom Line

I won’t hesitate to say that Kate eyeliners are the best you’ll find for lasting power, and for the price they’re the best for overall performance. However, if you find you don’t have serious issues with eyeliner lasting-power, you may want to look for a liner with more manageability.